Showing posts with label data. Show all posts
Showing posts with label data. Show all posts

Monday, November 16, 2020

Cone Dodgy Numbers

This post is not to be taken seriously. No seriously, I mean that. This post is where I attempt to guesstimate the results of my latest power improvements, and I will be venturing into the world of comparing results from different dynamometers and no such comparison should ever be trusted, but all too often it's the best we can do, so let me make some excuses, and then we can get on with the dubious number wrangling.

Click here to skip my rambling and just see the graph....

Theory


In theory the right way to upgrade a car's power is to do a several dyno pulls on dyno A before modification and then after modification calibrate and re-measure on the same dyno A. For further modifications, one would ideally have another before/after pull on Dyno A. Dyno B which is a different dyno altogether shan't be involved and dyno C is right out! 

Excuses


I didn't do that. Not because it's a bad idea but due to a combination of time constraints, weather and cost. After all, dyno time is not free.
  • Weather: Modifications of major magnitude are often done in the winter, and the decision to proceed often coincides with the onset of cold weather. Once the snow is up, toting around the 20ft trailer becomes a lot less fun. The risk of loosing everything I worked on due to one ice patch or similar is daunting because I'm not maid out of money. 
  • Time: If I would decide earlier in the season this would be less of a problem, but when engines, or major portions thereof are being replaced and the first event is early April, and one pulls the trigger after Christmas, adding a trip to the dyno into the schedule is dubious, especially since the engine builder wanted some key parts off the original to get started.
  • Cost, well dyno time isn't free, but the time off to visit a dyno is potentially even more expensive, and as I said, I'm not made of money.
Ok them's my excuses and that's that. (Well yes it does boil down to Gus is cheap and he procrastinates... shhh!) 

Also in this case there was a necessary switch in dynos because the dyno from last time was down for service, so even though I stuck with my Emtron ECU and my tuner Nick, I had to take it to a different location. 

Funny Math


Even using the same machine, day to day atmospheric difference can cause some variation, but as a rule aside from what the operator might do inputing measured temps/humidity/pressure there's little one can do to ensure equality there so one just hopes that that source of error is not significant. 

Beyond that the different brand of dyno have different overall reading tendencies, much of which is fuzzy despite no end of internet discussions on the topic. Obviously, in the real world a given pull releases X amount of heat energy, and Y % of that winds up being used to accelerate the dynamometer. In theory they should all get the same result but in practice they don't, and the proprietary nature of their software and hardware is such that it's bad business for any Manufacturer to clarify how their numbers relate to this theoretical truth. All that any consumer grade dyno actually guarantees is consistency for runs on that dyno (assuming consistent atmospheric conditions of course). For tuning an engine that's what's really required, and so no shop is going to invest in a system calibrated to a real world standard. Only large OEM's have that kind of budget, and they "simplify" things by measuring the engine outside of the car anyway. ("Brake" horse power).

So in the portion of the world not working with multi-million dollar test labs, we have to wing it. 

The dynos in question are a Dynojet (last build) and a Dyno Dynamics (this build). What we do know from the internet, and from the claims of my tuner is that Dyno Dynamics is among the "heat breaker" dynos. The readings from these dynos tend to be lower than the much more common and nearly industry standard Dynojets. Both the Nick and the world wide web say something like 10-15% lower readings for the same car on a DynoDynamics vs a Dynojet, but that's a really really huge range. For a 190hp reading that's a range of 209 to 219, and for a build that is comming off of a 193 Dynojet reading that's a 60% difference in how much power was added, and saying a range always leads the conversation into hemming and hawing in an unsatisfying way, so I want to pick a number and have some basis for it that is is only partly insane.

Rather than using an internet post with little or no known basis in fact, I'm going to lean on my knowledge of what changes are being made to the car and derive a "possible" factor to convert the new dyno readings to the scale for the old dyno. 

Some Logic?


Things I know about the effects of the changes to the car that are relevant to this exercise include:
  1. The Compression ratio changed from 11.5:1 to 14.0:1, and according to this page, that's supposed to give a 5.7% increase in power. This is based in hard physics including the Ideal Gas Law (PV=nRT) etc. so, unless something else changes, it should be fairly predictable.
  2. The RPM limit is being raised to 9200, this means peak HP is not comparable and we can't use that number for scaling things, we should be using peak torque instead.
  3. The new roller-rocker setup deletes the variable lift function and ignores the lower cam. The lower cam is so named because it functions in the lower RPM's, typically below 6200. Any measurement below the cam switch point in the old build has both cam and compression changes to account for, so it's hard to predict the change under 6200 rpm.
  4. The cold air intake was increased from 2.75" to 3" and the throttle body from 65mm to 70mm, so the upper RPMs are likely benefiting from that change as well as the compression change 
So it sounds like there's nothing left, but that's not quite true. I *think* its reasonable to presume that the air intake is never limiting the developed torque until after the torque peak. Other factors could limit it first, but with the torque increasing, the air is not limiting, and thus below the torque peak and above the cam switch in the old tune is an area that  should be valid for comparison where only the compression change should be having an effect. Conveniently torque peaks are also frequently reported on dyno sheets. That conclusion of course relies on the assumption that the port/polish jobs and valve flow are similar, but I have no reason to suspect changes there. 

One thing I'm leaving out is the effect of the lighter pistons, and the lighter crank, which probably provide a slight gain beyond the 5.7% because less energy is stored as kinetic energy in the rotating assembly, but I would also expect the belt driven external oil pump to have a little more drag than the O.E.M. internal pump, so I'm going to guess that those are both small and mostly offsetting each other.

So that seems to imply that I can have a solid expectation based on a very inflexible bit of physics for the change at the old build's torque peak. The old torque peak was 142.1 ft/lbs at 6750 RPM (luckily this is solidly above the cam switch) and the expected result is 150.2 flt/bs at 6750 RPM. Since the new build's dyno graph reads 132.5 at 6750 RPM, this says that the scaling factor to convert from this particular Dyno Dynamics to that particular Dynojet is approximately (150.2 ÷ 132.5 = 1.134 a. k. a. 13.4% ) Thus the new torque peak of 134.6 ft/lbs @ 7000 rpm translates to a Dynojet number of 152.5 ft/lbs @ 7000 rpm. 

The Result


This result is nicely reassuring since the scaling factor is nicely within both my Tuner's claims range and the range of what you find on the internet. Overlaying the new chart on the old chart, lining up the axes and scaling things to match the above 13.4% factor gets me a comparison chart like this:

Factored comparison of dynamometer results. Note that MPH marked at RPM are only valid for a 4.8 final drive setup. The stock final drive is 4.5, so the 61mph top on the stock trace is more like 67mph in a stock vehicle. Thus I pack this power into a 7% smaller MPH range to begin with.


So the theory of this build was that the top end would gain power and revs, and the bottom end would experience competing effects with CR changes having positive effects and cam changes having negative effects. The hope was that these two would offset each other and lead to an overall faster car. 

I'd say it kinda, mostly worked. 
  • 0-4000 rpm we lack good data from the prior build but what is there suggests a definite loss, but this loss is only at launch and only poorly designed courses spend significant time under 30mph. It does seem likely that launch bogging will be a difficulty, but that is < 5% of the course...
  • 4000-5000 RPM has smoothed out substantially for a small net improvement which is interesting because my scouring the internet for dyno graphs led me to associate that shape with the PPE Engineering exhaust header I'm using. the fact it went away without changing the header is interesting.
  • 5000-6200 RPM has lost some oomph, to the tune of about 10 tq. This is sad, and I did notice it when driving. It's hard to say what impact this will have. 37 to 45 mph is a common acceleration range so this is a bit worrisome. I'll be pondering any ways to improve this. Moving down to a stage 2 cam might help since stage 3 tends to be a peak hp cam. 
  • 6200-9200 RPM shows gains are strong and clear and on par with expectations. My build lacks an ITB intake and is clearly running out of breath at the very top, but hits a dynojet corrected peak of around 216 whp, and the ITB setups built by DRS post 220 to 225 whp. I had dared to dream that the big bore throttle body and bigger intake might allow me to capture all of that, but that was just dreaming and I know it. I suspect I did get ~10 hp out of that switch in any case since the hp peak is still around 8k and the compression alone can only account for 205 of the 216 (dynojet) hp. The fall off is faster however so I wonder if the rising intake velocity isn't compressing the foam filter or something. The intake is sold for 400hp supercharged cars but something is up... since the torque peak moved but the hp peak didn't.
So the net result is that my car has become a bit more course dependent, where faster courses should be much better, and slow stuff hurts slightly more. At the end of 2019 I drove 2 courses where I was riding the (then 61mph) rev limiter for 8-10 seconds on a 50 second course, raising the limiter alone is likely worth a half to a full second on such courses, and the power gains in the upper range hopefully worth .25 or .5 on faster courses. I'm hoping I only gave up a tenth or so on launch and no more than 1-2 tenths in the mid range. The only two courses I managed to run in 2020 were both pretty much a worst case scenario with very little time over 50mph (same course designer). I look forward to some faster courses in 2021 to get a real look at what it can do. 

The positive side of that is that most national level courses are faster courses... so it will be at its best where it counts the most. 

So now it's time for you to shoot holes in my assumptions in the comments section if you can :)

Tuesday, July 3, 2018

New Heights, and New DIY

Once again, I've been slacking on the blogging, but as you will see on the standings page, the season has been progressing, and I've got a co-driver who's giving me some solid competition. The first few events were Freezing, Soaked and Soaked, so I pretty much lacked anything inspiring to blog about anyway. I went to the new Jersy Pro Solo, and had not really found my stride after missing most of 2017 in my car and getting almost nothing but rain events in the early season. I just wasn't getting slip angle like I should, and I was quite dirty, hitting cones or red-lighting on many of my runs as well. As will happen at the national level, if you aren't in top form you're at the bottom of the standings...

Some how I didn't feel eager to write about that either...

However, the weather improved, and satisfactory driving has finally come to pass. I've now managed to regain my prior level of driving from 2016, and in event #5, I finally found a new high point. One of the tough things about evaluating one's performance in autocross is that all measures are relative and the reference point is constantly in motion. To make a sane evaluation one has to make some assumptions. My first assumption is that the top drivers in our region are not getting slower. Given our region's consistent 6-7 national champions the last 3 years this seems reasonable.

While I'm comfortable saying that the top of the heap is still at a high altitude, there are some other things that clearly have changed. Firstly our region has had a buble of talented drivers mature in the last 2 years. I'd not want to argue that any of them have really pushed the top of the pax standings up yet in the way that Billy Davis did in 2015 and 2017, but they have definitely crowded the top. In 2016 I had 3 events where I was 1.5s off top pax, which resulted in 15th, 10th and 15th in overall pax. This year at the last 2 events, 1.5s from top pax is worth 20th and 19th... So making the top 10 or top 20 is significantly harder than it was 2 years ago.

Secondly, pax for the SSM class has been hit harder than any others besides AM, BM and CSP. BM/CSP and SSM are all almost a full percentage point harder than 2016 relative to the other classes. This translates into about .44 seconds tougher pax on a 60 second (raw) course. I've made a spread sheet here that shows that while all pax factors (other than AM) went down, the average pax factor went down much slower for SSM. This probably has something to do with the last 3 champions Thorne, Glagola and Wilcox all hanging out in the top of pax at far too many national events...

With that in mind, the 20th in pax result that had me 1.5 seconds off of top pax in event 5 Looks a lot like what used to get a top 10 in 2016. And my 2.3 seconds off of top pax in event 6 looks a lot like a top 20 in 2016 even though it now shows as 30th. Kudos to my co-driver Daryl, who kept the car in the top 20 at event 6 with his 19th in pax. For 2 events running my car has been 2nd fastest car with doors. Here's a video of my 2nd fastest run from event 5, which is probably faster everywhere except the start where I forget to shift like an idiot... Sadly I didn't remember to turn on the camera for the fastest run.


Additionally, I've also done some more maintenance/improvement on the car. Another factor in my bad results at the New Jersey Pro solo was epic levels of wheel hop on my launches on day 2 when the rubber was creating a lot more traction. A lot of exhaust bounce had also been noted at Devens, and the result was too much for my front motor mount to take.



The alignment was checked and it was almost 6mm toe in, probably due to bushing migration. Soft bushings, lots of toe-in and enormous race tires are a recipe for massive wheel hop. There was only one conclusion, tired old plastic/rubber A-arm bushings had to go. I replaced them with Monoball metal/teflon spherical bearings from Inokinetic. Since this seemed like an interesting job, I also made a DIY video for it:


The results? FABULOUS. Both me and my co-driver Daryl noticed improvement in the predictability of the back end when rotating it around a corner, and improvement in braking. The first was expected and the second was a nice surprise. My rear suspension had probably become so floppy that the ABS probably triggered earlier. I also suspect this slop negated all rear braking once it triggered by wagging the A-arms back and forth with the ABS pulses. The start for this course did not lend itself to hard launches, and due to the late date of it's discovery I had to continue with the above mount after Ryan welded the split for me. Next event we will be doing full launches if the course allows it and then I expect to find that the wheel hop has also improved.

Monday, December 25, 2017

Return of the SoLoti

So yeah I got tired of blogging about how my car wasn't working... probably you got tired of hearing about it. Then when I finally got it working in September I spent all available weekend time driving it rather than blogging about it. I had a little bit of pent up racing to let out! Then I took on a new client and have had 1.25 people's worth of work to do...

So what's the story? Well, After waiting forever and then some for a valve tool to arrive at the shop that did the install of the head that was supposed to make it easier for him to check on the valve seals, I lost patience and took the car to MC racing, and they hooked up a compression tester and a leak tester, and whoosh... air in one piston and out the other... Clearly the head gasket was not sealing properly. Perfect proof that it is so very good that Nick my tuner at Ace Performance refused to tune with the car as I delivered it the first time. Kudos to them!

With this new information I contacted the original shop and they started pointing out that I supplied the head gasket etc... basically preparing excuses to not make it right. That sucked but there is of course enough gray area for them to avoid the work if they so chose. Fighting over it was clearly not a productive route to go, so I took it back to MC racing and for 2/3 the cost of the previous shop they took it apart, machined it, provided a head gasket and re-assembled it in working order. There's still a slight bit of smokiness, but nothing like before, and unlike before, when things warm up the smoke goes away. I suspect some things are not quite perfect due to the previous install, but now it's close enough that the thermal expansion completes the seal as the engine warms up. I'll be analyzing oil and keeping an eye on it going forward. If I ever go to high compression pistons, it won't be on this block/head combo.

Speaking of oil, I've moved to red-line 40wt race oil now that the car is a full time trailer queen and never does more than idle around before it's fully warm. In theory this allows a slight hp gain and better flow when warm, at the cost of a little more flow resistance (and thus wear) during startup. It's also the case that with a trailer queen, it is a lot harder to just bop on over to get an oil change, so I'll be moving to changing my own oil and brake fluid. To make that easier, and to help combat the flow resistance at low temp, I went to a Canton Racing  spin on oil filter which gives me about 3 times as much flow as the stock filter and 8 micron filtration.

I know what you are probably thinking... the man dumps umpteen zillion dollars into head work, ecu and tuning and he's blogging about his oil filter?? Point taken...  I'll get to the good stuff now.

So with it back together and (mostly) not smoking, tuning was possible, and the results are very pleasing indeed!


I never had a chance to get a baseline, so the above plot shows the results vs a stock plot I grabbed from the web and scaled to match. These numbers are a couple HP better than any other normally aspirated plot/numbers I've been able to find for cars running stock compression. And these are with the super trap on! Based on a single test run, there's perhaps another 2 hp in it if the super trap is removed. I only have good things to say about Nick's tuning, and Baer who runs Ace Performance was straightforward and easy to work with. I'm very happy to be promoting them on my wing plates!



The Emtron Ecu installed by Ace Performance has all kinds of super nifty logging and capability. No end of parameters to ponder! Below you can see the data, possibly even from the above photo. The slalom in the photo would correspond to somewhere around the 6000 second mark below, but I cant' be sure if it's exactly that run or not.



And I also got a beta version of CAN bus support for the stock dash, which so far seems to work great! Nick/Ace/Emtron will be coming out with new info on their products soon and when I'm allowed to share some stuff I've seen previews of, I'll post it here. Until then, we'll all just have to visit the garage, glance out the window at the snow and sigh... And comb through data logs :)